Skip to Content

Every item on this page was hand-picked by a House Beautiful editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

45 Easter Basket Stuffers That Are Fail-Proof in All the Right Ways

They're all tiny!

By Kelsey Mulvey and Jessica Cherner
easter basket stuffers
Soumi Sarkar

When it comes to snagging the best Easter basket stuffers, there’s only one rule to follow: Keep them small. After all, as their name implies, they’re meant to fit in a basket. In our opinion, Easter basket stuffers aren’t necessarily supposed to impress the recipient with their luxuriousness or hefty price tag. Instead, they should be fun, charming, and above all, a bit cheeky.

Read on for our favorite Easter basket stuffers for every member of the family. Whether you’re surprising the littlest ones under your roof or keeping the tradition alive with older guests, we rounded up our top picks that will surely garner a smile from anyone at your spring soirée.

For the Spa Goer

Coufuras 12-Piece Bath Bomb Set

12-Piece Bath Bomb Set
For the Spa Goer

Coufuras 12-Piece Bath Bomb Set

Now 17% Off
$25 at Amazon
Credit: Amazon

Bath bombs are the easiest way to relax at the end of a long week. Simply run the hot water until the bath is full and drop one of these in. Within seconds, it will start to fizz, releasing the essential oils and botanicals into the water, which not only smells delicious but also makes your skin super soft.

For the Holistic Healer

Before Noon Rose Quartz Crystal

Rose Quartz Crystal
For the Holistic Healer

Before Noon Rose Quartz Crystal

Credit: West Elm

Available in nearly every size, including one that's roughly the size of a mango, these raw stones make for a great Easter basket stuffer. Not only do they fit the pastel palette, rose quartz is said to promote love.

This Aesop hand cream is no ordinary moisturizer: it's a balm that boasts a rich herbaceous scent that will make you feel more relaxed as soon as you massage it into your hands. It takes a few minutes to absorb, but it's well worth the wait.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For the Note Taker

Papier Monogrammed Notebook

Monogrammed Notebook
For the Note Taker

Papier Monogrammed Notebook

Credit: Papier

Stamped with with gold ink to create a raised, metallic monogram, this Papier stunner is easily one of our favorites. Get it lined, unlined, or dotted, but be sure to tote it around with you everywhere because you never know when you'll need to jot something down in a hurry.

For the Troubled Sleeper

This Works Deep Sleep Pillow Spray

Deep Sleep Pillow Spray
For the Troubled Sleeper

This Works Deep Sleep Pillow Spray

Credit: Anthropologie

Forget the melatonin gummies and CBD oil. This pillow spray, infused with such soothing scents as lavender, vetiver, and chamomile, will naturally calm you down before it knocks you out. All you have to do is spritz it a few inches away from your pillow, lay down your head, and breathe normally.

For the Key Collector

Craighill Wilson Enameled Key Ring

Wilson Enameled Key Ring
For the Key Collector

Craighill Wilson Enameled Key Ring

Credit: Nordstrom

Key rings are one of those accessories no one wants to buy for themselves, but are thrilled to unwrap as a gift. Case in point: this sleek option from Craighill, which comes in red, navy, white, and gold.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For the List Maker

Knock Knock Plan of Attack Big Sticky Note

On Sale
Plan of Attack Big Sticky Note
For the List Maker

Knock Knock Plan of Attack Big Sticky Note

Credit: Amazon

Nothing makes daily chores more tolerable than checking them off a cheeky to-do list. This one, in sticky note form, is our top pick because it's brightly colored and organized by urgency.

For the Little Spoon

Terrain Ladybug Glass Spoons

Ladybug Glass Spoons
For the Little Spoon

Terrain Ladybug Glass Spoons

Credit: Terrain

These may not be your everyday spoons, but they're so precious that we couldn't resist throwing them on our list of Easter basket stuffers. After all, with their pastel tones and ladybug details, they scream spring.

For the Party Goer

Henry Handwork Embroidered Cocktail Napkins, Set of 4

Embroidered Cocktail Napkins, Set of 4
For the Party Goer

Henry Handwork Embroidered Cocktail Napkins, Set of 4

Credit: Food52

While we're on the topic of elevated household items, these hand-embroidered cocktail napkins are precious with their border detailing and charming cocktail-themed motifs.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For the DIY Doctor

Natural Life Pill Case

Pill Case
For the DIY Doctor

Natural Life Pill Case

Credit: Urban Outfitters

For the friend who always has something for every kind of ailment, opt for this charming antique-inspired stainless steel pill box. It features a split compartment inside, so all she has to do is pop in a few of her most used remedies, and she's ready to go.

For the Dessert Lover

Williams Sonoma Famille Rose Appetizer Plates, Set of 4

Famille Rose Appetizer Plates, Set of 4
For the Dessert Lover

Williams Sonoma Famille Rose Appetizer Plates, Set of 4

Credit: Williams Sonoma

Technically, these ornately decorated plates are meant for appetizers, but they're so small and beautiful that we'd use them during the best and last course: dessert.

For the Life of the Party

Lively Root Disco Ball Garden Hanger

Disco Ball Garden Hanger
For the Life of the Party

Lively Root Disco Ball Garden Hanger

Credit: Lively Root

Spice up your plant's living quarters with a hallowed out disco ball that, like the real thing, hangs from the ceiling. It may not spin, but it does bounce colorful sparks of light off the walls. It comes in two sizes, so feel free to use it for your one-leaf plants or your slightly bigger danglers.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For the Fire Starter

Maison DuPré French Match Strike

On Sale
French Match Strike
For the Fire Starter

Maison DuPré French Match Strike

Now 15% Off
Credit: Frontgate

Matches are one of those things that don't need to be pretty to serve their purpose, but these are an instant conversation-starter.

For the Perfume Addict

Boy Smells Exploratory Perfume Set

Best Seller
Exploratory Perfume Set
For the Perfume Addict

Boy Smells Exploratory Perfume Set

Credit: Boy Smells

If you ask us, having a signature scent is overrated. Why wear only one when you can experiment with seven? Whether you layer them atop one another or wear them on their own, you're sure to get asked, "What are you wearing?"

For the Beauty Junkie

Fresh Treat & Tint Lip Care Set

Editor’s Choice
Treat & Tint Lip Care Set
For the Beauty Junkie

Fresh Treat & Tint Lip Care Set

Credit: Sephora

It's not often that a lip product is as hydrating as it is colorful, but Fresh's famous Sugar balms are different. Not only do they glide on and infuse your lips with hydration and give you a pretty amazing color pay off. This set, all mini versions of the brand's best-sellers, includes a colorless balm and three berry-colored tints.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For the Candle Lover

Paddywax Impressions Candles

Impressions Candles
For the Candle Lover

Paddywax Impressions Candles

Credit: Free People

If you're in need of a fail-proof Easter basket stuffer, you can't go wrong with candles. These ones, though all different, smell refreshing and floral—perfect for Easter.

For the Sweet Tooth

Brightland The Couplet Honey Set

Editor’s Choice
The Couplet Honey Set
For the Sweet Tooth

Brightland The Couplet Honey Set

Credit: Brightland

Honey is one of those underrated ingredients that you can use for way more than tea. In fact, it's delicious in coffee, on avocado toast, and with cheese. This set from Brightland includes one classically colored honey that's infused with oranges and flowers, and a darker honey with notes of molasses. Both are quite different but equally delicious.

For the Easter Bunny

Kate Spade Bunny Ring Stand

On Sale
Bunny Ring Stand
For the Easter Bunny

Kate Spade Bunny Ring Stand

Now 16% Off
Credit: Kate Spade

Bunny motifs only really work on Easter, but we'll make an exception for this ring stand from Kate Spade. It's subtle enough that it doesn't look like it's part of a theme.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For the Musically Inclined

Janet Gwen Janet Gwen Rose AirPods Case

Janet Gwen Rose AirPods Case
For the Musically Inclined

Janet Gwen Janet Gwen Rose AirPods Case

Credit: Anthropologie

AirPods cases tend to get scratched and, even worse, dirty. So if you want to keep it pristine, tuck it into this blush-toned case that comes complete with a glossy gold-toned clip.

For the Champagne Drinker

Allison DeVane Minute Mimosa Sugar Cube Trio

Editor’s Choice
Minute Mimosa Sugar Cube Trio
For the Champagne Drinker

Allison DeVane Minute Mimosa Sugar Cube Trio

Credit: Uncommon Goods

Available in four flavors, these are no ordinary sugar cubes you'd drop in a cup of coffee or tea. Instead, plop one into a glass of Champagne or Prosecco, and it will turn into a mimosa or bellini. Our personal favorite? The shimmer peach and berries trio, which gives your beverage a little sparkle.

Headshot of Kelsey Mulvey
Kelsey Mulvey

Kelsey Mulvey is a freelance lifestyle journalist, who covers shopping and deals for Good Housekeeping, Women's Health, and ELLE Decor, among others. Her hobbies include themed spinning classes, Netflix, and nachos.

Headshot of Jessica Cherner

Jessica Cherner is House Beautiful’s associate shopping editor and knows where to find the best high-low pieces for any room.

Easter Ideas

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Logo
twitter icon
youtube icon
facebook icon
instagram icon
pinterest icon
Hearst Lifestyle and Design Group - A Part of Hearst Digital Media

A Part of Hearst Digital Media

We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back.

©2023 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy NoticeCA Notice at CollectionYour CA Privacy Rights/Shine the LightDAA Industry Opt OutTerms of UseSite Map
Cookies Choices