Finding gifts for your sister-in-law can be tricky. On the one hand, you want her to genuinely like it, and on the other, you don’t want her to think you’re trying too hard. And if your sister-in-law seemingly already has everything she’ll ever want or need, there's even more pressure to procure the perfect present. That’s where we’ll happily step in.
We’ve scoured the Internet in hot pursuit of the best presents that even the hardest-to-impress sister-in-law would be thrilled to unwrap. Don't worry, plenty of our top picks are also quite affordable. Think a scented candle that’s equal parts musk and floral for less than $20, a $100 three-piece cast iron cookware set, or a stoneware serving platter for less than $30. Otherwise, if you’re in the mood to splurge, you’ll find quite a few finds that are nothing short of luxurious like an Aesop hand balm, a super-sleek blender, a monogrammed velvet throw pillow, and the list goes on.
Overall, no matter what you decide to get your new sister, she’ll love it. Not to mention, it’s the thought that counts, right? So if you’re on the hunt for a gift worthy of your potential new best friend, you’ve come to the right place. Just be sure to pair your present with a considerate card (bonus points if it’s homemade). Go on and get shopping!
Milk Bar has been a dessert-centric institution since it opened its doors in 2008. Now, of course, there's a bigger selection of sweets that would appeal to just about anyone, so if you're looking for an easy crowd-pleaser, this is it.
This Aesop hand cream is no ordinary hand cream. In fact, the brand doesn't even call it a hand cream; it's a hand balm. It's made with mandarin rind, rosemary, and cedar atlas, but the heavenly scent isn't even the best part as your hands will never feel greasy or slimy.
Craft & Kin is one of our favorite brands for affordably candles that smell super luxe. Case in point: this smoke and vanilla one, which is equal parts musk and sweet. It's rich and delicious, making it a good go-to gift.
Staub is one of the best enameled cast iron cookware brands on the market. It's also surprisingly affordable considering the high quality. That said, it's not exactly cheap, so when we find a useful set on sale, we'll be the first to grab it. You can make just about any meal using these three pieces.
Technically, these are clogs, but she can wear them around the house as slippers because they are so cozy and warm. After all, we wouldn't expect anything less from the American-made bedding brand.
The only downside to blenders is they tend to be big and clunky. Such is not the case with the Beast blender, which is sleek and slender. And when you're done blending, simply screw on the drinking lid, and start sipping.
Nothing is more personalized than something monogrammed. Enter this charming velvet pillow that is bespoke in pretty much every way. Pick the color, the trim, the text, and even the font.
We love a good set, but sometimes, having multiple pieces that look completely identical can get boring after a while. That's why we love this kind of set. All four mugs go together, but they're totally different.
These are the kind of candles you may not want to light because they're so beautiful. In fact, they're hand-painted in White Plains, New York, so they're basically locally made art. If your sister-in-law is a regular hostess, these candles make for the perfect gift.
Like the hand cream (read: balm), this is not your typical hand soap. It's luxurious in every way, from the sensual citrus scent to the printed wrapping.
The name aside, Slip's Medusa gift set is hardly horrifying. Valued at $108, it includes the brand's classic silk pillowcase, a skinny silk scrunchie, and a large silk scrunchie. If your sister-in-law cares about the health of her hair and skin, she'll love this extravagant set.
The best way to bond with your sister-in-law is to spend some one-on-one time together. And if you aren't exactly the best of friends, adding some alcohol to the equation may take the edge off. This ribbed set from Anthropologie is perfect for wine, margarita, or martini nights at home.
A portable speaker comes in handy more often than you may think. Whether you're headed to the beach, the gym, or anywhere in between, creating a soundtrack to your relationship with your new sister is always a good idea. Did we mention it's waterproof?
All Béis products are designed with comfort in mind. From the fabric to the shape of the handles, you'll never get tired of carrying the weekender around. So if your sister-in-law is an avid traveler, she'll love this perfectly sized duffle bag.
Hear us out: A wreath is a perfect gift because, whether she lives in a house or an apartment, it will dress up her front door in all the right ways. This one is crafted with dried wildflowers harvested on a woman-owned farm in the Pacific Northwest.
LAFCO is a fragrance destination unlike any other. The scents are rich, fresh, and luxurious. These reed diffusers are available in the brand's most popular scents, including chamomile and lavender, Champagne, and gardenia.
Sadly, pajama sets seem to have been replaced with oversize tee shirts and college sweatshirts. So consider this our plea to bring back a classic set of pajamas. This one, from Sleepy Jones, is made of super-soft, breathable cotton.
The Citizenry is where you shop when you're looking for something artisanal, beautiful, and handmade. Available in three sizes, these trays are woven from locally-sourced palm leaves in Malawi, and offer the perfect finishing touch in any space.
If she's a regular coffee drinker, she'll love this Bean Box set, which includes four artisan coffees, four culinary-inspired chocolate bars, and tasting notes for pairings. Now that's a delicious pick-me-up.
Serena & Lily may be famous for its coastal-chic furniture that's often finished in wicker or white paint, but the beloved brand also sells an impressive collection of home-centric accessories. Our favorite? The waffled cotton throw that feels like silk.